Posted by: Jeanne In Utila | May 31, 2012

Four Lies about Poverty

Since moving to Honduras, I have had an education in poverty and am shedding my prejudices about it. Here are four lies I have discovered about poverty.

1. Poor people are lazy.

From what I’ve seen, the poorer the people are, the harder they work. When choices of work are limited, as is the case in Utila, the work is often hot and back-breaking. It is the work nobody else wants to do and they do it with little pay. And, there is no chance for advancement or a raise because there is always someone willing to work for less.

Man on bike selling watermelon on the streets of Utila, Honduras, Central America

Selling fruit on the streets of Utila.

2. Poor people don’t work as hard as the rest of us.

The poor are restrained by cultural, political and economic systems that do not reward their labor. For example, Ana works in a small store in the coastal city of La Ceiba, on mainland Honduras. She works 12-hour days, 7 days a week, and makes $10 a day. She has 30 minutes for lunch and is provided no break room or any place to eat. She finds a corner over by the dressing room to sit on the floor of the store and eat. When she has been at the store long enough to qualify for medical insurance, her employer lays her off for four days and then rehires her. The clock starts over, and she never qualifies for insurance. She can’t go to a company that doesn’t run this game because they all do it. She has no recourse, no employee rights, no choice, no chance to get ahead.

Man on bike carrying a long ladder on the streets of Utila, Honduras, Central America

Heading out to do a job that needs a ladder in Utila.

3. Poor people can change their circumstances aka “pull yourself up by your bootstraps.”

Often the poor are trapped in circumstances beyond their control. What if your father is in jail and your mother disappeared out of your life because she decided she wanted to live in the United States without you? You were seven years old when she left. You are being “raised” by an older brother.  Or, you never met your father and your mother is a crack addict? She sells your older sister on the streets at night to support her habit. Real life stuff. How do you  to pull yourself up by your bootstraps when you’re wearing flip flops?

Many circumstances the poor face are devastating: crime, gangs, violence, drugs, rape, prostitution, intimidation, domestic abuse, discrimination, exploitation, and economic deprivation.

One more thing to think about. Where would you be without your computer? Exactly. The poor don’t have computers. When I think about what I would do if I were born into poverty, I think I’d educate myself. But how? Computer of course. But, you don’t have a computer if you are poor. Oh, yeah, I forgot.

Kids in classroom learning English in Utila's public school, Honduras, Central America

Kids learning English in Utila…a second language opens more job opportunities.

4. Poor people don’t want help.

It’s hard to lift your head up when every day is a struggle to survive. Your kids are left to raise themselves when all your energy goes into finding a way to put food on the table. No matter how determined or enterprising you are, you cannot overcome the vicious cycle you find yourself in. You no longer believe anything will ever change. You have lost hope. Hope that tomorrow might be better or your children might have a chance at a better life. When life feels this futile, it’s hard to imagine a solution is available. The connection between work and payoff has been severed. Without hope, there is no energy to seek help or believe in it.

Question: What have you learned about poverty?

Garbage truck collecting trash, workers in Utila, Honduras, Central America

Garbage truck and workers in Utila. Hot, stinky, heavy, endless work. At least you get to rotate driving the truck.


Responses

  1. Jeanne,
    you made me cry. I’m so proud to be your friend. You get it and we need more people like you to get it.
    We’ll continue this conversation and I hope you can give a talk about this when you come back. We can have it at our house and invite as many people as we can pack in to hear more about it.
    Hugs.
    M

    • Marijana, thank you for your kind words. I know I have a lot more to learn about poverty but glad to be living in the midst of it so I see it first hand and hopefully learn it well. I appreciate you very much…your support and prayers. xoxo

  2. Thanks for the different perspective& in sight. Thanks for clearing up some commen myths u are truly God’s ambassador with His eyes.

  3. Hello Jeanne, I must admit you have really put in perspective some of the island realities I witnessed when vacationing on Utila. I remember once someone saying that we don’t know how “rich” we are to have “choices” but after reading your blog it gives that statement way more weight and it saddens me to think not only about those you have encountered but all of those who live without choices.

    Thanks for opening my eyes!

    God Bless

    • Barry, thanks for your comments. I love hearing your perspective.

      I do believe that choices are the key to human hope and possibility. I was reminded by a friend on the island who read this article that some people, rich, poor, or in between, don’t convert choices they are given to make a change in their situation. A case in point: a woman with six kids and a crack addicted husband isn’t motivated to work and help her family. She has been given numerous jobs and she fails to show up or when she does she is late and gives a halfhearted effort. She has lost every job that has been extended to her. The sad part is that her kids ultimately suffer in the long run. But, I think we all know people like this in every economic strata.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 114 other followers

%d bloggers like this: